Notes from Amy Spalding

Notes from Amy Spalding

Share this post

Notes from Amy Spalding
Notes from Amy Spalding
What's Inconsistent about Rent?

What's Inconsistent about Rent?

I ponder this important mystery.

Sep 07, 2023
∙ Paid

Share this post

Notes from Amy Spalding
Notes from Amy Spalding
What's Inconsistent about Rent?
Share

I Don’t Hate Everything.

Dear Readers,

My friend, composer/lyricist Christie Baugher, shared this article with me: Can ‘Candide,’ ‘Rent’ and ‘Spamalot’ Ever Truly Be Revived? [gift link], and pointed out this section to me:

An author should be so lucky as to have that problem, but it nevertheless is a problem. So is the meta-tragedy surrounding “Rent,” whose author, Jonathan Larson, died at 35 in the hours just before the show’s scheduled premiere. The work has essentially been frozen as he left it that day in 1996. Thom Allison, who directed Stratford’s production, told me that permission for even the tiniest change in the script, to correct an acknowledged inconsistency, was denied by the estate’s representatives.

Readers, I asked myself: what is the acknowledged inconsistency? The comments offer no firm answers. Here are some theories I’m putting forth:

  1. If there’s anything that doesn’t offer a break from the grind of New York life in one’s twenties, it’s the infamously risky and time-consuming restaurant industry, regardless of location.

  2. A completed song should not sound better than a song trying to complete a song.

Keep reading with a 7-day free trial

Subscribe to Notes from Amy Spalding to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 Amy Spalding
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share